Elomi Response: Allison- Please consider referring to How to Size a Bra Calculator on the "Herroom" website to help determine you're in the correct size. The puckering sounds like emptiness in the cup. If so, please consider elomi Abi Bandless Bra EL8100 in 36 D-8. Allison from Brighton, CO
Elomi Response: Please consider trying our elomi Abi Bandless Bra EL8100 in 40 D11. It is bandless for less coverage and features lighter construction that is particularly good for petite body types This style is the same bandless underwire frame as Victoria, EL8150 that you purchased. Keni from Washington